Can You Eat Muskie Fish (Here is the Answer…)

can you eat muskie fish
Last updated:

If you love to eat fish, you may often try eating different fish species to taste their flesh.

The muskie fish is a native fish of the pike family. This fish is not a predatory fish, but its appearance is a letdown for many people.

If you have tried other fish species, especially big games, you may need to try muskie fish once after your fishing.

But, the main question is can you eat muskie? The answer is yes.

You can eat muskie as much as you want. Still not

Despite being a game fish, this freshwater fish tastes quite good.

Those who prefer eating muskies say that this trophy fish tastes quite good.

It has a mild fish flavor, and the fish fillets can be cooked in different ways.

Many also say that the muskie tastes like a mixture of lobster and a wild brook trout fish.

Still not convinced? Here you can get all the details on how to eat muskie fish to get the best flavors and a delicious taste.

Can You Eat Muskie

Is there any regulation of fishing on muskie fish?

Muskie fishes are generally classified as big game fish species.

You can find these big game fish species in rivers, lakes, or streams where freshwater is available.

The department of natural resources regulates the fishing of muskie finishes to protect native species.

As per the department of natural resources, USA, one angler can catch only one muskie fish of a maximum of 1 meter per year.

Anglers who catch more than the prescribed limit need to catch and release the extra muskie fishes to maintain their population.

Due to excessive fishing, muskies gradually decrease in numbers in streams or lakes.

Hence the organization has taken some preventive steps to maintain a healthy population of muskie fishes.

On top of that, some states in the US, like Maryland, also have their own local regulations to battle decreased numbers of muskies.

Muskie fish important information

Muskie fish is an apex predator fish by nature. Muskies are also called ugly pike. They are known to be a voracious and big eater.

It is a freshwater fish that eats mammals and other fish species like wild brook trout, small mammals, and even poultry animals.

The regular muskie fish appears to be like the Northern Pike fish. This fish is known for its distinct flat head and longer body.

The female muskie fish is Larger than its male counterpart. An adult muskie fish can reach weights up to 31kg, with a general wait of 6 to kg.

Nutritional value of muskie fish

In general, the muskie fish is enriched with essential micronutrients.

These fishes are great as they are zero carbs and contain 88% protein in their flesh.

On top of that, muskie fish contains only 12% of unsaturated fats and healthy fatty amino acids.

Those who have high cholesterol can eat muskie fish as it helps maintain the cholesterol level in the blood.

On top of that, this fish can also prevent Alzheimer’s disease and promote better brain health.

Hence, it is great for those looking forward to eating healthy fish and offers better health alongside good taste.

Is it safe to eat muskie fish?

You can always eat muskie fish. This fish is found in large numbers.

Hence it is easier to catch muskie. You can also come across good quality muskie fishes while trout fishing.

It is one of the least endangered fish species as well.

In some places, dedicated muskie fisheries are also found that supply the tiger musky and other musky variants for those who love to eat muskie fish.

This fish is easily available near natural resources.

Although muskie is not a toxic fish, you need to be careful while cooking and collecting muskie fish.

This fish can contain many environmental toxins, germs, and harmful disease-causing microbes due to its eating habit.

If you are an over 15 years old individual, you can eat one muskie fish once a month or six fish per year.

Women who are pregnant or nursing their babies should refrain from eating muskie fish.

Muskie fishes usually have a higher mercury level in their flesh and y-shaped bones than any other freshwater fish.

On top of that, these fishes also have thick bones. Hence, it is better to procure muskie from a reliable source.

On top of that, it is advisable to properly clean and cut the fish before you eat muskie fish.

The best method of cleaning muskie fish

Before eating the muskie fish, clean them for safety properly.

The main challenge for cleaning muskie fish is their thick y shaped bones.

Here is a simple guide that can help you to make this task easier:

  • Tale a very sharp knife for making the muskie filets. You can get a special knife for filets. Alternatively, any sharp kitchen knife will work.
  • Now, cut the head behind the gill plate vertically.
  • After this, use a horizontal cut to slice the fish along its backbone.
  • Again use vertical cuts along the dorsal fin of the muskie fish.
  • Now, slide your knife parallel along the backbone to create two files. You need to slice it along its y shaped bones.
  • You will get two fine filets. Repeat the process on the other side to get more two filets
  • Now, remove the skin of the fish to get four complete fileted fish

After you have fileted the fish, add a few drops of lemon juice and vinegar to them.

This will remove all the germs and the strong fishy taste from the filets.

How to cook musky fish

Cooking musky is easy because its firm white meat is mild and tasty.

Here are a few innovative ways to cook and eat muskie fish.

Muskies taste good in almost every recipe, fried, sautéed, baked, anything.

Some people also prepare it like the landlocked salmon fish to enhance its taste.

If you are wondering how to eat muskie fish, choose any of these recipes from here-

You can cook a muskie like a regular wild brook trout.

A little bit of addition of herbs and spices can enhance the mild fish flavor of muskie perfectly.

1) Fish cutlets

Take musky fish filets, and you can prepare fish cutlets from these.

First, create breading of flour, paprika, and dried herbs, and add salt to this.

Next, prepare the egg wash separately.

Now, take a large skillet and add peanut oil to the skillet. Let the oil get hot.

After this, dip the white filleted fish into the breading and then egg wash. Create a few layers by repeating this process.

After that, fry them golden brown in the hot oil till the coating becomes crispy. You can also add reserved bacon fat to the oil to enhance the flavor.

2) Muskie fish and chips

The muskie filets are also a great option for making fish and chips.

The beer batter coating can also enhance muskie tastes.

It is better to use fine muskellunge filets for making fish and chips.

Make a fluffy batter with flour, salt, paprika, beer, or sparkling soda using a food processor. Keep the batter aside.

Now, take a hot pan and add peanut oil to it.

Dip the fish fillets in the batter and fry them in medium-high heat until golden brown.

In the same oil, fry some thick-cut fries till golden brown also.

You can serve the fish and chips with some wine vinegar, chilly or mayonnaise.

3) Pecan crusted muskie

It is a delicious gourmet meal prepared from muskie fish to delight your taste buds.

First, grind the pecan nuts in a food processor.

Next, make a mixture of crushed pecans, white wine, lemon juice, lemon zest, chopped shallots, and melted butter.

Now, coat the filets in the prepared batter. Press the filets to ensure the mixture sticks to the fish.

After this, take a  large skillet and heat it on the flame.

Add one or two filets at a time and cook each side for three to four minutes.

Now, prepare the dipping sauce. You can add reserved bacon fat, French melted butter, olive oil salt, lemon butter, or bacon bits to the dipping sauce.

4) Pan-seared muskie with bacon and tomato

Prepare this Italian-inspired pan-seared fish if you have plum tomatoes, bacon, or diced bacon and muskellunge filets at home.

Take one pound of plum tomatoes and cut them in half. Similarly, Dice 1 large stalk of leek.

In a large pan, add the diced leeks and reserved bacon fat to cook them for a few minutes.

Now, add two cloves of chopped garlic and two tablespoons of capers to this and cook for about a minute.

After this, add tomatoes and cook until soft.

Next, add bacon bits and nix everything altogether. Add some salt and pepper according to the taste.

Now, take a large skillet and heat it over a high flame.

Add olive oil to the pan and lightly season the muskellunge filets.

Now, bake the filets in a preheated oven at 375 degrees F for ten to fifteen minutes.

Please take out the backed fillets and add the prepared butter dipping sauce to them. Serve hot.

5) Oven-baked muskie

Take a properly clean muskie fish of ten to fourteen ouds and keep it aside. You can either use fish filets or a defined whole fish per your preference.

Now, grease the oven tray with butter and preheat your oven to 375 degrees F,

Season the fish with salt and pepper.

After this, properly coat the fish with butter.

After they bake the fish in the oven, ten minutes of cooking is recommended for each pound of weight.

After five to fifteen minutes, continue to add some more butter to prevent the fish from during out.

Bake it until the flesh is properly cooked. Serve hot with sides of mashed potatoes with bacon or steamed vegetables.

5) Tempura fry muskie

Due to the mild flavor, muskies also taste great as tempura fries. It is easy to prepare and warms you up instantly.

Take muskie filets and cut them into sized pieces.

Now, take a bowl, add tempura flour, season the flour, and add an egg.

After this, add some cold water to the flour and egg mixture to create a light and dripping tempura batter.

Take a hot pan and add peanut oil to it. Heat the oil for deep frying.

Now, coat the fish fillets in the batter and fry them until crisp.

Serve hot with soy sauce and some wasabi paste.

Since muskie fish is mild in flavor, you can also use it to make Chinese fish dishes like crispy fish and sweet and sour fish.

It goes well with tempura fry as well. Hence, you will never run out of innovative ideas to eat muskie fish.

Conclusion

Muskie fish also called muskellunge fish is an apex predator fish found in the rivers, lakes, and streams.

Its mild fish flavor and nutritional value make it a treat for anyone.

Those looking for answers to whether you eat muskie can get some help from here.

Before going for muskie fishing, check out the local rules and regulations and safety precautions to prevent unwanted situations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are the risks of eating muskie?

Although muskie is not a toxic fish, you need to take a few precautions. This fish eats everything, including fish, mammals, and small aquatic animals. Hence, any muskie fish can contain disease-causing microbes. On top of that, muskie fish is higher in mercury, resulting in adverse health conditions.
Those younger than 14 years old or pregnant or nursing women should not eat muskie fish without the consultation of their physician.

What does muskie taste like?

Those who eat muskie fish praise its mild fish flavor. The firm white meat does not have any strong fishy taste. It has a texture that is somewhat like the mixture of trout or bass with lobster meat.

What are the benefits of eating muskie fish?

Muskie fishes have 88% protein and 12 % unsaturated fat and essential amino acids. It promotes better brain health and also keeps your cholesterol level in control.

How much muskie fish can one eat?

One healthy adult (except pregnant and nursing women) can eat one muskie fish per month, up to six fish in a year.